9/15/06 11:57 am - Fox news get to re-write history now
I get the feeling this journal is quickly going to become friends-only musings on law school and public entries on things I find outrageous in the world. Because I have two right now.
First, Bush's press conference I'm listening to right now. He wants support for the interrogation bill before Congress, to clarify the Geneva Convention. Which sounds reasonable in theory, but in practice I'm really going to need someone to explain to me how "shocks the conscience" is any clearer than "outrages upon personal dignity, in particular, humiliating and degrading treatment". I just don't see how they are, and if there's one thing I've learned so far, it's that words are not clear; laws do not provide a whole lot of clarity. Unless you write a list of things you can and can't do, there isn't going to be a lot of clarity. Also, he's arguing with John McCain again on this, which prompts me to ask again: How can you argue with John McCain about torture?
In the end though, thanks to the Supreme Court, to a certain extent the point is moot, because they can't lessen the standards of the Geneva Conventions, just keep them same or raise them.
Second, and this is the one that really upset me, was an article in Fox news. I know, I know, why was I reading Fox news? Well, I was looking for a story about the violence in Chile last week, since I just heard about it, and the Fox news article was the one that popped up. It was the anniversary of the 1973 coup when Pinochet took overthrew Allende and took over the country, and there was a protest that got violent. In the process of giving a brief history of that time in Chile's history, Fox news said this:
"As the march reached the presidential palace, where Allende committed suicide the day of the coup rather than surrender to the rebellious military..."
Bullshit. For those of you who don't know much of Chile's history, this is a hugely disputed fact. The suicide was Pinochet's story about Allende's death during the coup. Nobody really knows what happened, but many people think he was killed. Allende was giving a speech to the people as the palace was being bombed; there's a recording of it.
Fox news does not get to state as fact disputed historical events. Especially not ones that the average American doesn't know much about and will accept as the truth.
First, Bush's press conference I'm listening to right now. He wants support for the interrogation bill before Congress, to clarify the Geneva Convention. Which sounds reasonable in theory, but in practice I'm really going to need someone to explain to me how "shocks the conscience" is any clearer than "outrages upon personal dignity, in particular, humiliating and degrading treatment". I just don't see how they are, and if there's one thing I've learned so far, it's that words are not clear; laws do not provide a whole lot of clarity. Unless you write a list of things you can and can't do, there isn't going to be a lot of clarity. Also, he's arguing with John McCain again on this, which prompts me to ask again: How can you argue with John McCain about torture?
In the end though, thanks to the Supreme Court, to a certain extent the point is moot, because they can't lessen the standards of the Geneva Conventions, just keep them same or raise them.
Second, and this is the one that really upset me, was an article in Fox news. I know, I know, why was I reading Fox news? Well, I was looking for a story about the violence in Chile last week, since I just heard about it, and the Fox news article was the one that popped up. It was the anniversary of the 1973 coup when Pinochet took overthrew Allende and took over the country, and there was a protest that got violent. In the process of giving a brief history of that time in Chile's history, Fox news said this:
"As the march reached the presidential palace, where Allende committed suicide the day of the coup rather than surrender to the rebellious military..."
Bullshit. For those of you who don't know much of Chile's history, this is a hugely disputed fact. The suicide was Pinochet's story about Allende's death during the coup. Nobody really knows what happened, but many people think he was killed. Allende was giving a speech to the people as the palace was being bombed; there's a recording of it.
Fox news does not get to state as fact disputed historical events. Especially not ones that the average American doesn't know much about and will accept as the truth.
sleepy
annoyed
happy
scared
relaxed